Generating added value through extrusion in the flour mill
by Christopher Rubin, Product Marketing Manager - Extrusion, Buhler, Switzerland
The extrusion
of grain-based, starch containing raw materials is a process allowing all but
boundless applications. Christopher Rubin, extrusion specialist in the Buhler
Pasta and Extruded Products Business Unit, explains the possible value generation
and benefits associated with the application of extruders.
Generating
added value through extrusion in the flour mill by
Christopher Rubin, Product Marketing Manager - Extrusion, Buhler, Switzerland
Extrusion
serves the food industry as an upgrading process on the one hand for
carbohydrate-based and on the other hand for protein-based raw materials.
With carbohydrate-based raw materials, starch occupies by far the most important place. Other polysaccharides such as cellulose and glycogen are especially used in the production of confectionary and in encapsulating processes.
Making additional products
Grain-based foods are staples throughout the world.
In the grain year of 2007-08, 2.1 billion tonnes of grain was harvested around the globe. The production plants of the food industry process millions of tonnes of grain every day. The most important intermediate product in this connection is flour.
In addition to baking flour, grain processing also produces dark flour and bran, especially when wheat is processed.
Extrusion technology is one of the numerous possibilities of further processing flour as well as the by-products obtained in grain grinding. It offers especially flour mills the possibility of increasing the value added that they generate. The most important products made by the extrusion process include breakfast cereals, breakfast flakes, baby foods, extruded breading (crumbs), croutons and modified flours and starches. These are used, for example, as binders in soups and sauces or in the baking industry.
Modified and ‘clean label’ as well
Modified flours are also called swelling flours. They are applied as binders, fillers, or freshness extenders in bakery products.
Swelling flours are characterised by their modified water absorption capacity and their solubility characteristics. It is possible by suitable selection of the extrusion parameters to adjust the viscosity of flour-and-water suspensions to the needs of customers or the requirements of a particular application.
When the correct amount of thermal and mechanical energy is introduced into the extruder, end products will be obtained which are soluble in either cold or hot water and which possess a certain bandwidth of viscosities.
The extrusion process is especially suitable for modifying flours because it completely eliminates the need for using chemicals.
Therefore, modified flour can be excellently applied as an ingredient in products to which the ‘clean label policy’ applies (no use of ingredients with e-numbers). When extruded swelling flours are used, it is enough to declare wheat flour on the ingredients list.
With carbohydrate-based raw materials, starch occupies by far the most important place. Other polysaccharides such as cellulose and glycogen are especially used in the production of confectionary and in encapsulating processes.
Making additional products
Grain-based foods are staples throughout the world.
In the grain year of 2007-08, 2.1 billion tonnes of grain was harvested around the globe. The production plants of the food industry process millions of tonnes of grain every day. The most important intermediate product in this connection is flour.
In addition to baking flour, grain processing also produces dark flour and bran, especially when wheat is processed.
Extrusion technology is one of the numerous possibilities of further processing flour as well as the by-products obtained in grain grinding. It offers especially flour mills the possibility of increasing the value added that they generate. The most important products made by the extrusion process include breakfast cereals, breakfast flakes, baby foods, extruded breading (crumbs), croutons and modified flours and starches. These are used, for example, as binders in soups and sauces or in the baking industry.
Modified and ‘clean label’ as well
Modified flours are also called swelling flours. They are applied as binders, fillers, or freshness extenders in bakery products.
Swelling flours are characterised by their modified water absorption capacity and their solubility characteristics. It is possible by suitable selection of the extrusion parameters to adjust the viscosity of flour-and-water suspensions to the needs of customers or the requirements of a particular application.
When the correct amount of thermal and mechanical energy is introduced into the extruder, end products will be obtained which are soluble in either cold or hot water and which possess a certain bandwidth of viscosities.
The extrusion process is especially suitable for modifying flours because it completely eliminates the need for using chemicals.
Therefore, modified flour can be excellently applied as an ingredient in products to which the ‘clean label policy’ applies (no use of ingredients with e-numbers). When extruded swelling flours are used, it is enough to declare wheat flour on the ingredients list.
Alternative to traditional processes
Another field of application for extruders is the production of breading (bread crumbs). Extrusion technology allows breadings to be made on the basis of a wide variety of raw materials. Whereas the traditional production method requires the use of high-protein flours such as wheat or rye flours for developing the gluten framework, all starch-containing materials can basically be applied in the extrusion process. This also enables the processing of lower-grade wheat flours or flours made from corn (maize), rice, or potatoes. Raw material quality fluctuations are easier to smoothen out in the extrusion process. In extrusion, dough leavening is achieved on the one hand through the expansion of the dough at the die, but on the other hand can also be controlled through chemical or physical raising agents.
Reduction of the energy costs
In addition, the extrusion process also allows different types of breading flours to be made (American bread crumbs, Japanese bread crumbs, cracker meals, etc.) without requiring any modification of the extrusion line.
Moreover, it is possible to accurately adjust the texture, colour, and particle size of the product. In terms of energy efficiency, extrusion is a process excellently suited for producing bread crumbs. Much lower water contents in the product recipe and short retention times ensure low energy costs, especially in the downstream drying stage.
Thus, with a capacity of two tonnes per hour, the energy costs per tonne of finished product are twice as high for the traditional process than for the extrusion process.
Furthermore, with a suitable setup, the extruder offers the flexibility of also allowing related products such as baking beans and croutons and even bread chips to be made on the same line.
By-products as a raw material
Extrusion offers additional advantages. It can also process raw materials such as very dark flours (low-grade flours) and wheat bran. Both are typically made available at low cost to the feed manufacturing industry.
With the aid of the extruder, these by-products can be transformed into high-grade foods.
They are extruded into breakfast cereals or are applied in a modified form as ingredients for other foods. Bran flakes are highly popular today. And extruded wheat bran may fetch a price that is double that of native wheat bran.
The opportunities for wheat bran as a high-grade food are vast. The high dietary fibre content of wheat bran gives the product a ‘healthy image’.
Utilisation of lower-price raw materials
The basis of all the products mentioned up to now, which can be made by the extrusion process, is grain flour.
This is one characteristic that extrusion shares with the conventional baking processes. The basic difference resides in the dough texture. The dough framework of conventional baked products is based on proteins (gluten or pentosans).
On the other hand, the texture of extruded products is based on starch. The raw material used for extrusion must have a starch content of at least five to 10 percent to ensure that the end product will have a stable texture.
But the protein content can be low, that is, below 10 percent. Flours with such a low protein content are normally unsuitable for baking purposes. As the flour price is determined, among other things, by the protein content, low-protein flours are less expensive than high-protein ones. The extruder therefore also allows low-price flours to be processed.
Extrusion
In the extrusion process, a material is forced through a defined aperture.
In order to ensure that this opening (die hole) is not choked, the material must be either completely or at least partially liquefied by subjecting it to the action of pressure and temperature.
But in practice, the extruder fulfils many more functions: conveying, melting, mixing (dispersion and homogenisation) and proportioning.
In addition, the material undergoes chemical and physical modifications during extrusion, for example starch gelatinisation or protein texturising. At the end of the extrusion process, the product is cut to size and thus shaped by a cutting device.
The raw material and the extrusion parameters determine the product characteristics such as texture, bulk density, colour, taste, water solubility and others of the extruded products.
Another field of application for extruders is the production of breading (bread crumbs). Extrusion technology allows breadings to be made on the basis of a wide variety of raw materials. Whereas the traditional production method requires the use of high-protein flours such as wheat or rye flours for developing the gluten framework, all starch-containing materials can basically be applied in the extrusion process. This also enables the processing of lower-grade wheat flours or flours made from corn (maize), rice, or potatoes. Raw material quality fluctuations are easier to smoothen out in the extrusion process. In extrusion, dough leavening is achieved on the one hand through the expansion of the dough at the die, but on the other hand can also be controlled through chemical or physical raising agents.
Reduction of the energy costs
In addition, the extrusion process also allows different types of breading flours to be made (American bread crumbs, Japanese bread crumbs, cracker meals, etc.) without requiring any modification of the extrusion line.
Moreover, it is possible to accurately adjust the texture, colour, and particle size of the product. In terms of energy efficiency, extrusion is a process excellently suited for producing bread crumbs. Much lower water contents in the product recipe and short retention times ensure low energy costs, especially in the downstream drying stage.
Thus, with a capacity of two tonnes per hour, the energy costs per tonne of finished product are twice as high for the traditional process than for the extrusion process.
Furthermore, with a suitable setup, the extruder offers the flexibility of also allowing related products such as baking beans and croutons and even bread chips to be made on the same line.
By-products as a raw material
Extrusion offers additional advantages. It can also process raw materials such as very dark flours (low-grade flours) and wheat bran. Both are typically made available at low cost to the feed manufacturing industry.
With the aid of the extruder, these by-products can be transformed into high-grade foods.
They are extruded into breakfast cereals or are applied in a modified form as ingredients for other foods. Bran flakes are highly popular today. And extruded wheat bran may fetch a price that is double that of native wheat bran.
The opportunities for wheat bran as a high-grade food are vast. The high dietary fibre content of wheat bran gives the product a ‘healthy image’.
Utilisation of lower-price raw materials
The basis of all the products mentioned up to now, which can be made by the extrusion process, is grain flour.
This is one characteristic that extrusion shares with the conventional baking processes. The basic difference resides in the dough texture. The dough framework of conventional baked products is based on proteins (gluten or pentosans).
On the other hand, the texture of extruded products is based on starch. The raw material used for extrusion must have a starch content of at least five to 10 percent to ensure that the end product will have a stable texture.
But the protein content can be low, that is, below 10 percent. Flours with such a low protein content are normally unsuitable for baking purposes. As the flour price is determined, among other things, by the protein content, low-protein flours are less expensive than high-protein ones. The extruder therefore also allows low-price flours to be processed.
Extrusion
In the extrusion process, a material is forced through a defined aperture.
In order to ensure that this opening (die hole) is not choked, the material must be either completely or at least partially liquefied by subjecting it to the action of pressure and temperature.
But in practice, the extruder fulfils many more functions: conveying, melting, mixing (dispersion and homogenisation) and proportioning.
In addition, the material undergoes chemical and physical modifications during extrusion, for example starch gelatinisation or protein texturising. At the end of the extrusion process, the product is cut to size and thus shaped by a cutting device.
The raw material and the extrusion parameters determine the product characteristics such as texture, bulk density, colour, taste, water solubility and others of the extruded products.